Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
40 minutes ago, natertater21000 said:

My best guess from judging all captions through the NFHS high cam (read with a grain of salt)

1.Cedar Park (it's REALLY close, like 6A 2022 close)
2.Rouse
3.Leander
4.Wakeland
5.Aledo
6.Lone Star
7.Argyle
8.Hendrickson
9.Burleson Centennial 
10.Roma
11.McKinney North
12.Friendswood
 

Had 10-12 in a different order but I'll take 1-9 correct.

Posted
15 minutes ago, natertater21000 said:

Incredible performances from everyone these past 2 days, "Texcellence" is alive and well. Crazy that this is only the beginning of the end for the competitive season, the next two weeks are going to be special!

agree. will not be surprised at all if cedar park medals at grand nats

Posted
19 minutes ago, Samuel Culper said:

Good luck with that. 😁

Argyle would be the band to do it. They would have made 5a state the very first year they were a 5a but it wasn't a state year that time. The next year they were in a state spot prelims but unfortunately dropped down. This year they kept their spot from prelims to finals. Essentially, since Argyle has been a 5a only one run hasn't been state worthy which is unheard of. Also 4a to 5a is the biggest jump a band can make and Argyle made it look like it was nothing. Argyle will dethrone Cedar Park eventually.

Posted
50 minutes ago, Atssbsax1 said:

Argyle would be the band to do it. They would have made 5a state the very first year they were a 5a but it wasn't a state year that time. The next year they were in a state spot prelims but unfortunately dropped down. This year they kept their spot from prelims to finals. Essentially, since Argyle has been a 5a only one run hasn't been state worthy which is unheard of. Also 4a to 5a is the biggest jump a band can make and Argyle made it look like it was nothing. Argyle will dethrone Cedar Park eventually.

try not to make it obvious you go to argyle challenge, level IMPOSSIBLE 

Posted
53 minutes ago, Atssbsax1 said:

Argyle would be the band to do it. They would have made 5a state the very first year they were a 5a but it wasn't a state year that time. The next year they were in a state spot prelims but unfortunately dropped down. This year they kept their spot from prelims to finals. Essentially, since Argyle has been a 5a only one run hasn't been state worthy which is unheard of. Also 4a to 5a is the biggest jump a band can make and Argyle made it look like it was nothing. Argyle will dethrone Cedar Park eventually.

Argyle didn't make state last year, getting 5th at area B. Not sure if that's what your trying to say lol, just super confused. However, Argyle is getting really good, really fast.  

Posted
1 minute ago, PercDad4Life said:

As a percussion centric fan, something seems off with the final results.  Aledo Percussion jumped from 13th in prelims to 1st in finals.  That is a BIG jump for a group who has a stellar band but not normally in the discussion for percussion prowess.  

I get that subjectivity is always part of the scoring, but this raises some suspicion in my mind. Especially given that there was no change in band placements from prelims to finals.  The judging was pretty consistent, except for percussion. 

Does anyone else find this mildly suspect?

You have a completely different set of judges for finals then what you had a prelims. So, it could be a result of tastes between the two j

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...