Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Finals Placements: 

1. Cedar Park

2. Rouse

3. Wakeland 

4. Lebanon Trail

5. Argyle

6. Leander

7. Aledo

8. Lone Star

9. Burleson Centennial

10. Jack C Hayes

11. Richland

12. Mccallum 

apologies for any spelling errors

Posted
2 minutes ago, Argyleauntie346 said:

I’d like to say something about these finals rankings today: I am disgusted with the conclusion the judges came to. It is disrespectful to neglect what bands like Lonestar offered musically and visually. Placing them at eighth is a sign of ignorance and injustice, displayed by the judging panel here today. Just because a band doesn’t have perfect balance on the field as they would in a concert room, or doesn’t put Beethoven or Mozart in their show, shouldn’t subtract from their music score as it most definitely did today. Understandably, picking famous names/composers to judge a state level marching competition will result in outcomes reflecting a concert band perspective. I’d like to urge for a reform in future UIL marching band judging panels!

So you don't want to reward bands that perform as well marching as they do in a concert setting? Okay...Cedar Park didn't put Beethoven or Mozart in their show. For someone who's been watching marching band since the early 70s you sure seem like you are just learning about competition marching...

Posted
5 minutes ago, Argyleauntie346 said:

I’d like to say something about these finals rankings today: I am disgusted with the conclusion the judges came to. It is disrespectful to neglect what bands like Lonestar offered musically and visually. Placing them at eighth is a sign of ignorance and injustice, displayed by the judging panel here today. Just because a band doesn’t have perfect balance on the field as they would in a concert room, or doesn’t put Beethoven or Mozart in their show, shouldn’t subtract from their music score as it most definitely did today. Understandably, picking famous names/composers to judge a state level marching competition will result in outcomes reflecting a concert band perspective. I’d like to urge for a reform in future UIL marching band judging panels!

im crine😭😭😭😭

Posted

I find it interesting Richland's content and design score dropped all the way from 6th in prelims to last in finals, I thought out of all the captions this would be the most consistent and unchanging but it ended up being the most volatile, anyone know why this could be?

Posted
27 minutes ago, Argyleauntie346 said:

I’d like to say something about these finals rankings today: I am disgusted with the conclusion the judges came to. It is disrespectful to neglect what bands like Lonestar offered musically and visually. Placing them at eighth is a sign of ignorance and injustice, displayed by the judging panel here today. Just because a band doesn’t have perfect balance on the field as they would in a concert room, or doesn’t put Beethoven or Mozart in their show, shouldn’t subtract from their music score as it most definitely did today. Cedar Park absolutely deserved this win today; however, winning content and design having no props and a show named “listen” with little to no general effect is… not just. Simply because the band has won every single other year shouldn’t mean that they get first in almost every single category this year. Understandably, picking famous names/composers to judge a state level marching competition will result in outcomes reflecting a concert band perspective. I’d like to urge for a reform in future UIL marching band judging panels! 

This isn't BOA. Props are much less important for UIL. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...