Clarinot
-
Posts
1,388 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
11
Posts posted by Clarinot
-
-
-
are predictions going to go up soon? im pretty sure in like 2 or 3 weeks are the first competitions of the season.
Unfortunately a lot of the finalized rosters aren't released, so we typically wait to avoid errors in our predictions lists. I did get BOA McAllen added, but everything else (Austin, for example) has a list from May so it likely has a lot of changes.
-
I'm basically in the matrix
- LeanderMomma and gregorydf01
-
2
-
We did try to make a feature of the site that does this... the score archive, but sadly no one has been interested in really keeping it up to date.
-
Hi everyone! Just a heads up that predictions can now be made for next week's contests!
-
-
My bad on the rankings not being updated. I cleared out the scores from 2016, so now what you see should just include BOA Austin scores (and anything thereafter)
-
In a sense, the directory section of the website is somewhat of a relic of a different era of the website. When I built the website back in 2005, that and the forums were the first thing I created. Sure it was cool to go and see your school in the directory, but are people looking up things besides that? The site has shifted from the forums being super active with a lot user-generated content to a focus on the live blog almost exclusively.
It has admittedly gotten harder to "moderate" the directory as well. Back in the day, I created it wiki-style, where any registered user could go in and add schools, make updates, etc. Eventually though, I got sick of merging duplicates (we would have "Clear Creek", "Clear Creek High School", and "Clear Creek H.S." all with separate entries, for example) so we moved to the current method with the "tell us what needs to change" button and a free text field. While this has definitely helped with invalid entries, it makes it a lot harder for the moderator to update anything because you have to cross reference a bunch of user submissions and also have the database open - a lot of work for someone. If there is value in it, we could definitely look at going back to the original update method.
More importantly though, there may be a lot of
gained from really breaking down the directory into just a combination of data from other places on TxBands.com. Already the contest results section of each school's card is just an overlay of data from "Scores" - could the predictions game feed all it's data into scores? Probably! Any suggestions on how we can make these pieces of the site more sustainable and valuable are always welcome. -
Sorry for the delay in response to your question, JTApex!
Predictions is designed to support events with up to 14 finalists (i.e. a BOA Super Regional). When the analysis is calculated we take every participating band in the list and look at how people are predicting them. Every time a band appears in 1st place on a prediction list they receive 14 points. Second place gets 13 points. Third place, 12 points, etc. Those points are summed per band and each school is ranked.
Probably not super scientific. We're always open to tweaking anything if someone out there has a better suggestion on how to analyze the data.
-
Thanks - I cleaned up the extra LSP contest (the 3 people who predicted on the deleted event also predicted the one I kept, so nothing was lost). Mansfield event deleted as well. All scores from this past weekend have been entered.
-
Marching season always creeps up on me! I added all the BOA Texas events for prediction: http://www.txbands.com/predict/
State can't go live until we have area contest winners, and area predictions can't go up until the results from regional contests are finalized, so that will be later.
If there are additional, non BOA events that you'd like added, please feel free to post them here, or you can add them yourself at the following link:
http://www.txbands.com/predict/public_addevent.php
Keep in mind, some events don't lend themselves to the way TxBands predictions work such as events where there are multiple divisions and classes, rather than a standard 1 through 10 ranking.
-
They keep coming up with new tactics and we have to go in and thwart them. Rinse and repeat.
-
-
-
Yep, I've fixed the error and will post back on how to update your list this afternoon
-
Yep, it's definitely a challenge to keep everything up to date. We're always looking for volunteers to help create content for the site/forums. Just let me know if you're interested!
- azn and NickTheDrummer
-
2
-
Agreed - it can be a daunting task to verify and update all the information. That said, anyone who is interested in helping out, feel free to let me know and I can give you moderator access to the directory.
-
-
Done - sorry for the confusion!
-
Can someone point me to the roster/schedule?
-
Sorry, I made a mistake while archiving the live blog -it's back - http://live.txbands.com
-
Sorry you're having trouble with it, I'm not sure why this is happening. Could you try to log out and then back in? I made a change yesterday that should have made it "remember" logins between the forums and the rest of the site.
-
Okay cool - well predictions are up!
-
Yes, I'll put that up tonight. Also, are you talking about IM? Do they have predictions?
Forums Updated for 2020!
in Events on TxBands.com
Posted
Thank you - this is really helpful! It was definitely intentional to make these changes in the slow period of the site so I can uncover some of the inevitable bugs. I spent a lot of time on the rest of the site outside the forums, but our forums are actually a commercially available software package (invision board) to which we made minimal modifications.