All the opinions expressed have their merits. As a retired music teacher and adjudicator who follows Texas bands, may I weigh in? I don’t adjudicate marching although I understand and appreciate it, but I do adjudicate music in another area. The elements that must be in place are flawless intonation, dynamic rise and fall of phrases, proper attacks and releases, and of course basics like balance and blend. The music should connect with the intended audience on some emotional level. The group should transition flawlessly through meter changes. Music difficulty is not just based on how fast or high a passage is, but whether there are difficult leaps in the brass to lock in, whether throat tones in the clarinets are in tune, etc. Vista Ridge had that package locked down. Did you notice the mixed meters they used? Makes marching a bit trickier, and they did it so flawlessly that I didn’t catch it the first time I saw them. Did they connect with the audience? Most definitely. If you saw them in person, did you notice how their facial expressions and body movements mirrored the music? Also they used minimal props and used them well; that appealed to me (although I did love some of the cool props used by other bands as well). That was showmanship at the highest level. I can’t wait to see what they bring next year.
That said, wow! What amazing performances from so many-Flower Mound, Ronald Reagan, Leander, Vandegrift, Hebron-more than I can even mention-Texas bands are fierce and fine! It is a joy to be able to immerse myself in the Texas band culture in the fall because I truly believe it is the strongest in the country. I think judging any marching festival would be extremely difficult given the diversity in show concepts and drill. Glad I don’t have to, but I can sit in the stands and appreciate the efforts of each group. I love BOA and have been to Indy, St. Louis, and Atlanta when it was still there. I enjoyed seeing what each area of the country brings to the field. Most of all I love seeing kids work so selflessly together to bring their best, to grow as musicians and people, and to entertain and awe us with their accomplishments.