I think it is important to mention that 4a for several years has rewarded bands to play basic things very cleanly. We all saw it happen with argyle, and celina winning with the very same blueprint. Multiple bands have been punished for trying to go out and experiment against the normal cookie cutter type of show, for instance, China Spring, and over the years bands have realized that 4a will forever be this way. That is why bands, like China Spring, who have an amazing sound, while having flaws, has seemingly done worse compared to everyone else, need I remind you that in the past five years have transitioned from a Fully military style (2020 placing 10th in finals) and every year since implementing more and more of the corp “cookie cutter” style, they have achieved a better placement in finals. I think the whole “park and bark” comment made about sulphur springs and china spring, while yes they have started implementing that more and more, is very oblivious to how the 4a grading has shifted them. Bands like Celina have taken advantage of this system and won. Not trying to disregard anyone for their wins, no matter the year, all students work very hard on their shows and the results are the results. But using Celina as an example as the band who does not “park and bark” is outrageous. While Celina had been very clean, to say they have not contributed greatly to the 4a grading standards, is absurd. Congrats to all for their achievements, and I look forward to seeing all of the bands at state.
P.S - it is worth noting I am a China Spring Alumni, and a part of the Military -> Corp style change. I can say that this year, while we aren’t going for our usual style, I am really enjoying the show and how cleanly you have done. However, do not get complacent. Carry the torch us alumni have passed onto you and give everyone a show no one can argue isn’t the best. It won’t be easy, but show them your Champion.