flutelolbro

While this is true, we can't really compare them to Argyle. Argyle became state champs with no other band being even close to them and were also beating more 5A bands when they were 4A compared to Celina. The main reason Celina were state champions was because Argyle left and is barely holding on to that spot when competing with bands like Panther Creek. After seeing the cutoffs that have been released, Wakeland is 100% going up to 6A as the cutoff is 2215 and they have 2446 if I remember correctly.

If you want to keep it as a ratio, you could do something where if one band from that area gets a medal, you could change the state qualifier ratio from 5:1 to 4:1 for that area (even if 2 or 3 medalists are from the same area that area will only have a ratio of 4:1 but could add 1 or 2 extra spots if more that one finalist is in the same area to show off more competitive areas). This makes it so there are maybe 3-7 more state spots which I think is fair.

I don't think we need a medalist rule for UIL. However, for changing the amount of area bands needed for a state slot, I think we should decrease in from 5 bands to 4 bands. Anything lower than that would lead to too many state slots.

They had an enrollment of 1230 so they'll probably stay in 4A.

Heritage has decided to go to the contest this early? I guess they believe they can be more successful next season considering they skipped this competition last year for Plano East. I guess we'll wait until next season starts to get some predictions.

Here are the bands I believe should be at this area next year (these are not in order of what I think their placements will be next year in any way and is just a list): Lovejoy HS Sherman HS Denison HS Anna HS Melissa HS Community HS (moving up from 4A) Celina HS (moving up from 4A) Aubrey HS (moving up from 4A) Argyle HS Denton HS The Colony HS Ryan HS Prosper Richland HS (moving up from 4A) Panther Creek HS (moving up from 4A) McKinney North HS (extreme rezoning) Frisco HS Reedy HS Frisco Memorial HS (they are not moving down to 4A) Frisco Liberty HS Frisco Independence HS Emerson HS Frisco Heritage HS Frisco Centennial HS Lone Star HS Lebanon Trail HS Schools leaving this area: Prosper Walnut Grove (Moving up to 6A) Wakeland HS (May or may not move up to 6A but I've seen more people say they are moving up to 6A) There are 25 schools that are basically guaranteed to be in this area. This means there are 5 state spots in this area if every band makes it to area. I won't make any predictions until the season starts because some bands could be better or worse depending on many factor that a band can and can't control.

From what I saw in the Realignment forum, Community might move up to 5A with Celina which means there could be 25 bands with 5 bands at state.

We have to remember that Melissa did a TON of cleaning after that and before area to get their area finals result plus the fact that McKinney is pretty early in the season. If we're talking about area, Celina will at the worst be at the bottom half of finals or in the bubble for finals and at their best be competing for 5th or 4th if they are rezoned to 5A Area B.

Vandegrift turned in 2361 so they will stay in 6A.

It probably won't go any lower than 2225

I think he meant that they got 4th in prelims but 5th in finals last year.

Do we know who the judges for this contest and their captions are?

The contest is being held at Coach Kenny Deel Stadium in Melissa.

I uploaded a recording

Is anyone here going to region on Saturday?

As a student from Heritage, our band director talked to their band directors and the reason was just to give the kids the weekend off so that they could catch up on some well needed rest and other things so they could put their all into the next two weeks.

I personally think that the top 2 are most likely going to be the same. However, I do think that 3-10 could be in almost any order and that any of these bands could make finals. I also wouldn't be surprised if some of these bands didn't make finals and some other Frisco school made finals here instead.

Area B will almost definitely have Wakeland and Lone Star at state. I think after seeing their bands and some results I think pretty much any of the finalists and even some bands that might not make finals have a small chance of making state.

They made 11th in prelims so they were pretty close. They also just had not as good of a run as they did the week before. I'm sure they're definitely motivated to do better so Area is going to be even more interesting.

If you’re thinker of the show about X, then you’re talking about Memorial. Independence went before Memorial so you might have gotten them mixed up.

Lone Star won visual

Heritage 7th

Garland 12th North Forney 11th

Can you please talk about the bands in Frisco ISD that are going to be in the showcase and this competition😁

Can anyone who is going to the Frisco ISD marching band showcase talk about the shows of the Frisco schools tomorrow?