Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
8 minutes ago, Clamp said:

I’m seeing a lot of judging that I don’t agree with this new judging system and has truly changed up everything 

this is the same top five as last year

Posted
2 minutes ago, CincoFan27 said:

this is the same top five as last year

I think it should've been more close cause judge 3 putting morton ranch over Cy woods taylor tompkins is absolutely crazy.

Posted
9 minutes ago, Clamp said:

I’m seeing a lot of judging that I don’t agree with this new judging system and has truly changed up everything 

Would like to share that the percussion judge said JET's perc writing "lacked nuance and uniqueness" and felt "blocky and unfitting." (placed JET 18th in perc)

If you're gonna judge a contest, especially one like UIL, you can't be opinion based. It's not fair to the performers on the field who are making the best of what they're given (not saying I agree with his critiques). I don't see much evidence of a new judging system at all. Most things seemed to have remained the exact same as they have every other year and this contest is still equally as unpredictable.

Posted
12 minutes ago, Clamp said:

I’m seeing a lot of judging that I don’t agree with this new judging system and has truly changed up everything 

It will definitely take some time for the directors/judges to get used to this new judging system. Area E had some surprises. 

Posted

1. Bridgeland +0

2. 7 lakes +2 

3. Cy woods -1

4. Cinco Ranch +1

5. Cy fair -2

6. Jordan +1

7. Tompkins +1

8. JET -2

9. Langham +0

10. Katy +0

All the same bands in the top 5 and bottom 5 of the top 10 things just switched around a bit in those bubbles, this is their ranking this year vs last year and the difference so a +1 would mean they went up 1 place

Posted
15 minutes ago, foeyamod said:

Would like to share that the percussion judge said JET's perc writing "lacked nuance and uniqueness" and felt "blocky and unfitting." (placed JET 18th in perc)

If you're gonna judge a contest, especially one like UIL, you can't be opinion based. It's not fair to the performers on the field who are making the best of what they're given (not saying I agree with his critiques). I don't see much evidence of a new judging system at all. Most things seemed to have remained the exact same as they have every other year and this contest is still equally as unpredictable.

Yeah the percussion guy was all over the place he had cy parks ranked I think 11th

Posted
25 minutes ago, foeyamod said:

Would like to share that the percussion judge said JET's perc writing "lacked nuance and uniqueness" and felt "blocky and unfitting." (placed JET 18th in perc)

If you're gonna judge a contest, especially one like UIL, you can't be opinion based. It's not fair to the performers on the field who are making the best of what they're given (not saying I agree with his critiques). I don't see much evidence of a new judging system at all. Most things seemed to have remained the exact same as they have every other year and this contest is still equally as unpredictable.

Can’t be opinion based? Huh? 

Posted
1 minute ago, ndndbfjfj said:

It's already on Compsuite, but I don't have access to it.

 

Well yeah. It's just not released to the public yet.

Posted
Just now, bassboneman said:

Well yeah. It's just not released to the public yet.

I think some people have it due to them being apart of the finalist bands but won't release it due to the directors I think.

Posted
On 10/22/2025 at 8:29 PM, CincoFan27 said:

May be bias but I feel like cinco is being ranked too low just because they haven't been to a contest in a week or two and y'all haven't seen how good they've gotten

Was I right?

Posted
15 minutes ago, CincoFan27 said:

Was I right?

I am super pleased y'all made it this year. It's going to be such a fun experience going to state for the first time (at least for the current set of students).

Posted
11 hours ago, tubapop said:

Can’t be opinion based? Huh? 

Not my point at all. Sure they can judge based on how clean and effective they 'think' the music is, but can you really say, as a judge, "wow, that color guard choreography is very clean, but I'm going to give you a bad score because I don't like it."

'Opinion' as in personal preference.

Posted
2 hours ago, ndndbfjfj said:

I think some people have it due to them being apart of the finalist bands but won't release it due to the directors I think.

I have never seen that stop anyone. Someone  always leaks it every year without fail.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...